Table Summary of Case
Studies combining theories with features of chatroom talk
Features of chatroom discourse
In this thesis I argue that it
can be shown that in chatroom discussion for the period 1995 to 2001, there
were new, unique features which made chatroom talk a new genre of writing. I
provide evidence that these features included the use made of emoticons and
abbreviations; threads and discontinuity; fleeting text; lurking; avatars and
usernames and collaborated-selves as author. Another feature of chatroom
discourse is grammatical errors and misspelt words. The nature of the spelling
is not the same as creating new words or not knowing the spelling of words but
words written in haste to keep pace with other ‘speakers’ in the chatroom.
Several methods
for the analysis of chatroom conversation have been developed. This was done
firstly by applying a number of different theories so the analysis of the case
studies in order to list the value of each in these instances. As a result, I
have and I have modified each method in order to develop an Online Discourse
Analysis Theory. The theories I applied to these case studies were Reading-Response Theory, Computer Mediated Communication, Semiotic
Analysis and Pragmatics, Speech Act Theory, Discourse Analysis, Conversational
Analysis, Linguistic schools of discourse analysis.
Through
a series of selected case studies, I identified special features of chatroom
talk evident in the time period of the case studies. Through my study of these
cases and the analytical uses of certain theories in relation to these, I have
developed a theory of ‘Online Discourse Analysis Theory’. This illustrates which
examples from the chatrooms.
# |
Theory |
subject |
Type |
Methodological focus |
Chatroom Features |
Response |
Storm |
topic |
Web of authorship, readership & subjectivity |
|
|
CMC |
IM |
1on1 |
Introduces the technology into the communicative act, and reveals the multi-layeredness of the chat |
|
|
Semiotic Analysis |
Spears |
Star topic |
Introduces a socially-embedded reading of communication still regarded as symbolic activity. |
|
|
Speech Act |
Astro |
topic |
What a 'speech act' is when it is conducted in written: an altogether different coding. |
|
|
Discourse Analysis |
Scud/b-witch |
general |
Symbolic (language) and the (embodied) social/cultural, as linked within practice. |
|
|
CA |
3D |
Mod-un |
Focuses right in onto the details of communicative exchanges CREATE A CA CODING TO HANDLE CHAT ‘THREADS’ |
|
|
(linguistic schools) |
Base ball |
topic |
|
|
I have
taken six existing theories used in analysing conversation, and applied these
to text based chatroom conversation. Furthermore, I have used theories from
several linguistic schools to further analyse online conversation. My research
has revealed features of chatroom talk which are new as discourse devices and
therefore which makes this form of communication different from other forms of
communication, such as person to person conversation. There are also features
of text-based chatroom conversation that are different than other online
formats, such as email and discussion groups.
Drawing
from existing theory, I have formulated new methodologies to analyse
conversation in text-based-chatrooms. I have limited myself to describing only
several of the unique characteristics in each of the chatroom case studies. In
this way I have sought to keep my examples clear; though, in many instances,
the material and new features I have described could apply to more than one of
my case studies. I will demonstrate from the results of my research in this
thesis, that the new and unique features of text based
chatroom discourse make it a new genre
of writing.
Case Study Summaries continue at: http://se.unisa.edu.au/s2.htm
[1] List of chatrooms
running 3D avatars and virtual worlds. http://dmoz.org/Computers/Internet/Cyberspace/Online_Communities/